Wood planks


Spicy Cheese

Cheese & Butter

We stock over 80 varieties of cheese products manufactured largely by different cheese-making operations in the Amish Mennonite communities of Indiana and Ohio.

Large Selection of Cheese

A few of our customer's favorites!

  • Raw Milk Cheese
  • Organic Cheese
  • Grassfed Cheese
  • Goat Milk Cheese
  • Amish Butter Cheese
  • Smoked Gouda
  • Horseradish
  • Roasted Garlic
  • Swiss on Rye (Caraway)
  • New York Sharp Cheddar
  • Vintage Habanero
  • Lacey Baby Swiss
Yoder's Smoked Provolone

Yoder's Smokehouse

Our smokehouse gets filled with more than just meat.

We smoke a variety of our specialty cheeses, such as our smoked provolone on the left as well as many others. Our slow smoking process takes cheese to a new level!


Try Our Butter!

Amish Roll Butter,
Salted or Unsalted
2# rolls or buy it in bulk, by the case!

Hartzler Butter 2# rolls
Growth Hormone Free!